http://nz.biz.yahoo.com//080730/26/71yh.html
(Adds regulator comment, details, background)
WELLINGTON, July 31 (Reuters) - A New Zealand court has
backed the competition regulator and barred rival grocery firms
from bidding for the country's biggest retailer, The Warehouse
Group Ltd (NZX: WHS.nz) , according to a judgement released on
Thursday.
The Court of Appeal overturned a lower court decision and
ruled that Australia's Woolworths Ltd (ASX: WOW.ax) and local
co-operative Foodstuffs cannot bid for The Warehouse, in a deal
that could be worth more than NZ$2 billion ($1.5 billion).
In its ruling, the Court of Appeal set aside earlier
clearances granted by the High Court, and ordered the two
supermarket chains to pay costs to the regulator.
The Commerce Commission said the decision was a victory for
consumers and competition.
"New Zealand consumers know that more competition is needed
in the supermarket sector," said the Commission's chair Paula
Rebstock in a statement.
"The Commission considered that the presence of an
innovative third party, such as The Warehouse, had the
potential to increase the level of competition in this
important market."
Shares in The Warehouse closed on Wednesday at NZ$3.82, and
have lost 33 percent so far this year, compared to a 18.7
percent fall in the benchmark top-50 .NZ50 index.
The Commerce Commission initially declined applications to
buy The Warehouse last June, saying that if either chain bought
the discount retailer, it would result in a substantial
lessening of competition.
However, the two grocery giants appealed and last November,
the High Court found in favour of the supermarkets, so the
regulator took the case to the Court of Appeal.
The Court of Appeal said it would release the reasons for
its decision, once it had decided what commercial information
submitted by the supermarkets should remain confidential.
Woolworths was reported by media to have approached the
Warehouse board with a NZ$7.15 offer, and was seen as winning
any takeover battle because of it had greater financial clout.
The Warehouse sells a broad range of general merchandise in
its 85 "Red Shed" stores. It is about 50 percent-owned by
founder Stephen Tindall and interests close to him, while
Woolworths and Foodstuffs each own about 10 percent.
The Warehouse has said it expects a profit for the year to
the end of July of NZ$84-88 million, up to 27 percent lower
than last year, on a sharp fall in consumer spending.
It competes against Briscoe Group Ltd (NZX: BGR.nz) , KMart
(ASX: WES.ax) and the privately owned Farmers department store as
well as smaller specialty retailers.
($1=NZ$1.36)
(Reporting by Adrian Bathgate)
|